Investment comparison

Explore the significant differences between pooled investments such as unit trusts (UT’s) and private share portfolios (PSP’s).
Unit Trusts and Private Share Portfolios - An overview

There are significant differences between pooled investments such as unit trusts (UT’s) and private share portfolios (PSP’s). PSP investing involves a bespoke investment portfolio in which shares and other securities are held in the client’s name, and are bought and sold on behalf of the individual client by the asset manager. The asset manager will invest directly in the market and will avoid investing through middlemen, like unit trusts.

Asset allocation and share selection within the portfolio can be customised to suit the client’s precise risk-return objectives. This may range from equity-only portfolios through to more conservative portfolios focused on giving investors a high-income yield. A PSP can also exist within a wrapper such as a retirement annuity or preservation fund.

Why switch?

Global trends show that as investors and advisers demand greater transparency, there is growing appetite for PSP’s as part of an overall investment solution. Given the wider choice, flexibility on fees, enhanced agility, and greater transparency, South African investors are increasingly following this global trend.

Recent performance figures compared
The differences side by side

Below we highlight some of the key differences between Private Share portfolios and Unit Trusts:

PRIVATE SHARE PORTFOLIOS
UNIT TRUSTS
Bespoke

Portfolio can be tailored to individual’s unique needs and risk-return objectives.

One-size-fits-all

Each client receives the same UT. See-through analysis and effective diversification remains difficult.

Segregated in client’s name

More meaningful exposure to less liquid smaller cap shares in a smaller segregated portfolio. Asset allocation shifts, which historically explain 80% of outperformance, require a high level of agility.

Pooled
Agility is often lost to UT’s due to their larger size.
UT’s can be cumbersome – the larger they become the worse they are likely to perform.
Active management
Funds are invested opportunistically over a period of time.
If cash needs to be raised this can be done by selling the weakest holdings at the time, which also helps improve performance.
Passive management
Funds are not invested with the individual client in mind. Funds are invested in a single day raising the risk of poor market timing.
Cash is raised by selling units of the entire pooled portfolio rather than select shares.
Personalised service

High level of engagement. Clients have direct access to the asset manager and client relationship managers.
Clients can receive instant feedback.

Public communication

All communication is via public media. There is no personal interaction with the asset manager.

Transparent & flexible fee structure

Incredibly transparent fees. Total fees should not exceed 1.5% per annum and are flexible for larger portfolios.

Rigid and complicated unit trust fee structure

Too many middlemen all charging fees including custodial fees, audit fees, legal fees, trustee fees, distribution and marketing fees, platform fees, and performance fees. Not all associated costs are included in the Total Expense Ratio.

Capital gains tax (CGT) planning

CGT is levied every time a share is sold. Clients will pay CGT every year, making full use of their CGT annual exclusion, and locking in relatively low CGT rates. South Africa’s CGT rate is low by international standards and will inevitably increase.

No capital gains tax planning

CGT is only levied when investors sell the UT which means CGT may not be paid for a number of years. While beneficial over the short-term the CGT rate is likely to rise over time making the eventual total CGT liability is far greater.

we will guide you
Exit strategies and Capital Gains Tax

Investors can exit a PSP at any time. There are no exit penalties, but CGT must be paid. For PSP’s the R30,000 CGT annual exclusion is used every year. The annual exclusion cannot be rolled over to the next year – it is a “use it or lose it” benefit. Unlike a UT, there will not be a single massive CGT shock when you exit a PSP.

Conclusion

Unit trusts are typically big mass-market retail products. They tend to be cumbersome and expensive. In contrast, PSP’s are smaller boutique-style wholesale products. They are agile, user-friendly and more affordable.

Cutting edge Investing

Get in touch with our team to find out more about switching to Private Share Portfolios.

Advisory Services

We offer advisory services on estate planning, trust structuring, money market options and foreign exchange assistance. Learn more

Weekly Market Report

We prepare a weekly report containing insights into indexes, markets and global events that may affect your investment. Learn more

Interested?

We understand investing is about more than just wealth. Allow us to help you chart the course.

Unsure about something?
Feel free to contact one of our experienced team members with your queries.

Please complete all fields:

Stay on top of the latest market news.

Get weekly market insights

Each week our team shares the latest insights into markets, indexes and global events, and how they affect your investments. To receive this valuable information simply fill out the form alongside.

Please complete all fields: